Off-Market Multifamily Buildings for Sale in Staten Island

15 off-market multifamily buildings in Staten Island, 5 added in the last 30 days. Asking prices run from $99K to $2M (median $900K). Shared by owners and brokers on the Crezly daily feed; most never reach the public listing sites.

$1,900,000

Multifamily Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

Added Oct 27, 2026

$99,000

2 Family Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

2 units

Added Oct 23, 2026

$1,225,000

Multifamily Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

Added Oct 19, 2026

$125,000

2 Family Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

2 units

Added Oct 15, 2026

$1,350,000

Multifamily Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

Added Oct 9, 2026

$740,000

2 Family Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

2 units

Added Oct 1, 2026

$1,450,000

Multifamily Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

Added Oct 1, 2026

$2,000,000

Multifamily Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

Added Sep 15, 2026

$675,000

2 Family Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

2 units

Added Aug 21, 2026

$1,950,000

9 Unit Multifamily Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

9 units · 7,300 SF · 10.5% cap

Added May 8, 2026

$695,000

2 Family Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

2 units

Added Mar 25, 2026

$745,000

3 Family Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

3 units

Added Mar 5, 2026

$1,300,000

2 Family Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

2 units

Added Feb 25, 2026

$900,000

2 Family Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

2 units

Added Dec 24, 2025

$555,000

2 Family Staten Island

Multifamily · Staten Island

2 units

Added Dec 2, 2025

Other off-market property in Staten Island

Off-market multifamily buildings in other boroughs

• Staten Island market report →
• Staten Island property records →

Frequently asked questions

What do off-market multifamily buildings cost in Staten Island?
Across the 15 off-market multifamily buildings on Crezly in Staten Island, asking prices run from $99K to $2M, with a median of $900K.

How do I get the address of an off-market property on Crezly?
Exact addresses are shared privately. Tap Inquire or WhatsApp on any listing and the Crezly desk sends the details, usually after a short non-circumvention agreement (NCNDA).

How often are new off-market deals added?
Every weekday. Owners and brokers share new deals through the Crezly WhatsApp feed each morning, and this page updates with them automatically.

Can I list my property off-market with Crezly?
Yes. Submit it on the List an off-market property page and it can go out to Crezly buyers without a public listing.